Love & Prayer

The Best Christmas Cookies

The Best Christmas Cookies

Every Christmas we may find ourselves either baking the same traditional cookies or trying to find a new recipe. Well, look no more! These vanilla sugar Christmas cookies are so good and buttery and yet no overly sugary, they are just the perfect cookie. Make them your own by decorating them with sugar icing!

Ingredients you'll need:

  • 12Ā ouncesĀ ButterĀ 350gĀ 
  • 3/4Ā cupĀ SugarĀ 150gĀ 
  • 2Ā tspĀ Vanilla extract
  • 2Ā tspĀ Salt
  • 2Ā Eggs
  • 3-3/4Ā cupsĀ FlourĀ +2 Tbsps, 500g


  • Cream the butter (I prefer to use cold butter) and sugar together in the bowl of a stand or hand-held mixer until light and fluffy (about 3 minutes if you start with cold butter).
  • Add the eggs, vanilla and salt and mix until smooth. Next add the flour and mix until just combined.
  • Take two large pieces of parchment paper and divide the dough in half, placing each dough half on top of the paper. Top each dough with another piece of parchment and press down a bit.
  • Take a rolling pin (or wine bottle if you don't have one) and roll the dough out to the thickness you desire (I like about 1/4" thick, but thicker is good too) between the sheets of parchment. Place each flattened dough on a cookie sheet and freeze for at least one hour (or up to several months)!
  • Preheat the oven to 350F. Once the dough is cold and solid, grab your cookie cutters and cut the cookies out (waiting a few minutes if the dough cracks from being too cold) and place them on a parchment-paper lined cookie sheet. Bake until the edges are just starting to get golden. Let them cool on the cookie sheets before removing.

While they're cooling down you can prepare your royal icing to decorate. Make sure they're completely cool before icing.


Stay Inspired.
Stay Connected.

Sign up for Heartfelt Harmonies our free Weekly newsletter.